6 min read Imports

The real cost of an import: everything that isn't on the supplier's invoice

Freight, insurance, duties, storage, inland transport. If they aren't allocated onto the goods, you sell believing you're making money and the real margin is something else.

The mistake you pay for while selling

The foreign supplier's invoice says a number. That number is not what the goods cost you, and treating it as if it were is one of the most expensive margin mistakes there is.

Between the supplier and your shelf there's a list of costs that, depending on the product and the origin, can add a very considerable percentage to the purchase price:

  • International freight and insurance.
  • Duties and other import charges.
  • Customs broker fees and documentation.
  • Storage, demurrage and handling at the port.
  • Inland transport to the warehouse.

When all of that is booked as the month's expense instead of allocated onto the goods, inventory is understated and every sale reports a margin that doesn't exist.

How to allocate, and why the basis matters

Allocation isn't trivial when a shipment carries different items. The usual bases:

  • By value. The expensive absorbs more. It's the sensible basis for insurance and for charges calculated on value.
  • By weight or volume. It's the sensible basis for freight: what takes up more space costs more to bring.
  • By units. Simple, and almost always wrong when the items are heterogeneous.

A container with light electronics and heavy tools allocated by value loads the freight onto the electronics, which hardly weigh anything. The result: one product artificially expensive and another artificially cheap, and wrong pricing decisions on both.

The practical answer is to allocate each cost by its own basis: freight by weight or volume, insurance and duties by value. A single basis for everything is easier and gives a worse cost.

The timing problem: the costs arrive later

The practical complication: the goods arrive and start selling before all the expense invoices are in. The customs broker's comes two weeks later; the port demurrage, a month later.

If you wait to have everything, you can't sell. If you receive with no costs, the cost is born wrong. The way out is to work with an estimated cost on receipt and adjust it as each real expense arrives, with the system recalculating what has already gone out.

And that's where the costing method matters: the later adjustment behaves differently under average cost than under FIFO.

What the system should solve

  • An import file that groups the purchase and all its expenses, with what's still outstanding in plain sight.
  • Allocation by the basis that fits each cost, not one basis for everything.
  • Receipt at an estimated cost and a later adjustment with nothing redone by hand.
  • The final cost visible by item and by shipment, so you can compare origins.

Purchasing and supplier payments

On the same topic

Knowing what it really cost you

Zyntello Purchasing keeps the import file with all its expenses, allocates them by each cost's own basis and adjusts the cost as the invoices arrive.