Average cost or FIFO: which to use, and why almost nobody can switch later
The decision looks like an accounting one and it's a business one: it changes the margin you see, the value of inventory and what you declare. And changing it later rewrites history.
The question almost nobody asks at the start
You buy the same item three times at three different prices. You sell one unit. What did that unit cost you?
There's no single answer, which is why costing methods exist. The two most used in the region:
- Average cost. Each receipt recalculates a weighted average, and issues go out at that average. It smooths the ups and downs.
- FIFO (first in, first out). What goes out is the oldest, at its original cost. The stock that remains is valued at the most recent prices.
With stable prices it hardly matters. With prices that move — which is normal in imports or with exchange rates — the difference in the reported margin is large.
What really changes when you pick one
- The margin you see on each sale. With prices rising, the average gives a cost lower than the last purchase price, so the margin looks better than replacing the item will be.
- The value of inventory on the balance sheet. FIFO leaves stock valued at recent prices; the average, at a blend.
- What you declare. Cost of sales changes, and with it the result.
- Pricing decisions. Setting the sale price on an old average cost while prices are rising is like selling at last year's price.
The most practical risk of the average in a rising market: you sell at a positive accounting margin and it isn't enough to replace the same unit. The report says you made money; the till says you didn't.
Why switching later is so expensive
Here's the surprising part: a costing method isn't a switch. Changing it forces you either to recalculate history or to cut at a date, and either one breaks the comparability of your reports.
What's more, in many accounting frameworks the policy has to be kept over time and a change has to be justified. It isn't something you decide on a Tuesday because the numbers look nicer.
The practical recommendation: decide it at go-live, in writing, with the accountant present — not the day someone notices the margin doesn't add up.
What breaks either of them
The method doesn't matter if the input data is wrong. What invalidates costing, whichever it is:
- Receiving with no cost. A receipt at zero poisons the average forever and throws no error.
- Leaving import costs out. Freight, insurance and duties are part of the cost, not a separate expense. We cover it in the real cost of an import.
- Adjusting quantities to paper over a cost problem. An adjustment keeps the cost: it fixes nothing and hides the cause.
- Entering the supplier's invoice at a price different from the receipt's without the system recognising the difference.