6 min read Purchasing control

Order, receipt and invoice: the three documents almost nobody matches

You overpay because nobody matches what was ordered with what arrived and with what gets invoiced. The control is three-way, and it always fails at the same point.

Three moments, three documents, three figures

A purchase goes through three moments, and each produces its own document with its own figure:

  • What you ordered — the purchase order: agreed quantity and price.
  • What arrived — the goods receipt: what actually went into the warehouse.
  • What you're charged — the supplier's invoice.

When all three match, you pay without thinking. The control is not paying anything where the three don't match. It sounds obvious; almost nobody does it.

Where it always fails

The interesting part is that the failure is hardly ever in the invoice. It's in the middle:

  • Goods are received without checking against the order. The warehouse notes what arrived, without looking at whether it's what was ordered. If 95 of 100 arrived, the difference surfaces weeks later.
  • What's invoiced is what was ordered, not what was received. The supplier invoices the full order and nobody cross-checks it with the partial receipt.
  • The invoice price isn't the order price. An increase nobody authorised, and it gets paid because the invoice is already approved.
  • Goods arrive with no order. The hardest case: something turned up that nobody formally ordered, and now you have to decide whether to pay for it.

Returns to the supplier are the most neglected point: the goods go back, and if that isn't linked to its credit note, you end up paying the full invoice for something you no longer have.

Tolerances, which are what make the control usable

A control that blocks over a cent gets switched off within a week. That's why you need tolerances, and deciding them is part of the job:

  • A small quantity difference in bulk goods is normal; in equipment, it isn't.
  • A price difference within an agreed margin can go through; above it, it goes to approval.
  • And above all: what breaches the tolerance isn't blocked in silence. It goes to someone who decides, by name.

What you gain, beyond not overpaying

  • You know what you owe before the invoice arrives. Goods received and not invoiced are a real debt, and if they aren't recorded, your liabilities are incomplete.
  • Inventory cost is formed on receipt, not on invoicing, which is when it should be formed.
  • You measure the supplier with data: how long they really take, how often they deliver short. That feeds the reorder point.

Purchasing and supplier payments

On the same topic

Pay for what was ordered and arrived

Zyntello Purchasing matches order, receipt and invoice with the tolerances you define, and whatever falls outside goes to a named approver.