Cost centres: why they get set up and then nobody uses them
They go up with enthusiasm at go-live and three months later half the expenses land in «general». Why it happens and how to make them survive.
The pattern that always repeats
It's one of the most repeated stories in any rollout: cost centres get defined by branch, by department or by project, carefully configured… and three months later most expenses go to a generic one.
When that happens, the cost-centre report doesn't just stop being useful: it misleads. It shows a cheap department because its expenses ended up somewhere else.
Why they die
- There are too many. Whoever keys an invoice has to pick from forty options. They pick the first one or the generic one.
- Nobody knows which one applies. A maintenance expense at a branch — does it go to the branch or to maintenance? If it isn't written down, each person decides differently and the report mixes criteria.
- They aren't mandatory. The field can be left empty, so it is.
- Nobody looks at the report. And what nobody looks at stops being filled in. It's the root cause behind nearly all the others.
- Some expenses belong to several at once — rent, electricity — and there's no allocation rule, so they go whole to one or to none.
How to make them survive
- Start with few. Five that get used are worth more than forty filled in at random. You can open more once the five work.
- Let them propose themselves. The cost centre is inferred from the supplier, the expense type or who requested it. The person confirms, doesn't choose.
- Mandatory where it matters. Not everywhere: on the expense accounts where the analysis is worth something.
- Automatic allocation for shared ones. Rent is split by a fixed rule — square metres, headcount, revenue — defined once.
- Have someone look at the report every month, visibly. If a centre's owner receives their spend and answers for it, the data cleans itself.
The check that tells you whether they're alive: what percentage of last quarter's spend went to the generic centre. Above a third, cost-centre analysis can't be used to decide anything.